Earth and environmental science 2016 HSC exam pack (archive)
2016 Earth and Environmental Science HSC exam paper
Marking guidelines
Marking guidelines are developed with the exam paper and are used by markers to guide their marking of a student's response. The table shows the criteria with each mark or mark range.
Sample answers may also be developed and included in the guidelines to make sure questions assess a student's knowledge and skills, and guide the Supervisor of Marking on the expected nature and scope of a student's response. They are not intended to be exemplary or even complete answers or responses.
Marking feedback
Select from the sections below to view feedback from HSC markers about how students performed in this year’s exam.
Use the feedback to guide preparation for future exams. Feedback includes an overview of the qualities of better responses. Feedback may not be provided for every question.
Feedback on written exam
Candidates showed strength in these areas:
- identifying specific earthquake resistant building features (Q21)
- naming appropriate technologies used to predict volcanic eruptions (Q22)
- drawing divergent and convergent plate boundaries (Q23)
- recognising the use of computer simulations or photographs as models to enhance understanding by providing a 3D visual representation (Q24b)
- drawing on case studies to link strategies to causes of erosion (Q27)
- explaining the processes involved in both dry land and irrigation salinity (Q28)
- identifying a well-known banned pesticide and outlining its effect on non-target species (Q29)
- identifying local and global strategies to decrease methane emissions (Q30a)
- distinguishing between climatic and human factors that may have led to the extinction of the megafauna in Australia (Q31).
Candidates need to improve in these areas:
- describing the causes of intra-plate earthquakes (Q21a)
- identifying valid reasons for continued research into the prediction of volcanic eruptions (Q22b)
- labelling diagrams to indicate significant geological features and causes of plate motion (Q23)
- identifying criteria to determine the validity of a secondary source (Q24a)
- explaining how early life contributed to the formation of BIFs (Q25)
- identifying the difference between oceanic oxygen and atmospheric oxygen in the formation of banded iron foundations (Q25)
- identifying and describing depositional environments of sedimentary rocks such as fossiliferous shale (Q26b ii)
- providing a clear explanation and evaluation of an erosion control strategy (Q27)
- engaging with the information given in the question, in this case using the components of the maps in an analysis (Q28)
- detailing specific, valid impacts on human health of a banned pesticide using recent/current research (Q29)
- using the data provided as a justification for a response (Q30a)
- demonstrating a link between wetlands and biodiversity (Q30b)
- detailing why models are used in science and providing advantages/limitations of their use (Q31)
- providing a planned and succinct response (Q31).
Question 32
Candidates showed strength in these areas:
- providing specific examples
- explaining the dispersal mechanisms of plants (part b)
- identifying simple trends on a line graph (part c i)
- referring to data in graphs to support an argument (part c ii)
- outlining data that identified and classified introduced species or named a recognised introduced species (part d i)
- writing concise points on the Bradley method (part d ii)
- naming examples of introduced species and providing reasons for their introduction (part e)
- providing information on Australia’s changing attitude to introduced species (part e)
- using evidence of specific examples to support assertions (part e)
- organising a response so that it reads in a logical sequence and provides in-depth knowledge (part e).
Candidates showed weakness in these areas:
- providing additional detail to enhance a description or explanation
- explaining effective dispersal mechanisms of animals (part b)
- identifying more complex trends in graphs (part c i)
- interpreting economic data from the graph (part c i)
- demonstrating an understanding of biological control when making an argument about the future use of biological controls (part c ii)
- correctly using the data and trends in a graph to support a prediction or judgement (part c ii)
- listing the specific equipment necessary to collect data (part d i)
- proposing a method of data collection that could account for the presence of the introduced species (part d i)
- describing a survey of sufficient size, including multiple quadrats and length of transects(part d i)
- providing detail about the effect the introduced species has had on the environment (part e)
- providing a clear judgement and supporting this with scientific evidence (part e).
Question 33
Candidates showed strength in these areas:
- linking the answer to energy conservation (part a)
- relating the discussed exploration program to the use of drilling (part b)
- connecting drilling to mining potential in terms of obtaining samples of the coal that could be tested for quality and estimates of the overall size of the deposit (part b)
- extrapolating trends in a graph (part c i)
- making a clear prediction regarding the long-term sustainability of the fossil fuel resources (part c ii).
Candidates need to improve in these areas:
- detailing methods of building design rather than just methods of energy conservation (part a)
- understanding that drilling can be used to determine both the size and quality of the deposit (part b)
- making reference to the stimulus provided (part b)
- making specific use of data from a graph to support predictions (part c ii)
- demonstrating a clear understanding of scientific method and the skills required for such investigations (part d i)
- relating coal to its use as a raw material for industry (part d ii)
- answering the question in the space provided (part e)
- addressing all the requirements of the question (part e)
- making a clear and well supported judgement with justification (part e).
Question 34
Candidates showed strength in these areas:
- making reference to the stimulus provided (part b)
- making effective use of the data provided in the graph to show trends (part c i)
- making use of specific data from the graph to support a prediction (part c ii)
- sketching in general terms the role of drilling regarding BOTH the size and grade of a metal deposit (part d ii)
- demonstrating understanding of exploration methods (part e)
- proving a clear justification with examples of society’s changing approach (part e)
- demonstrating a coherent and logical progression of thought with effective.
Candidates need to improve in these areas:
- detailing the features of ONE model such as the hydrothermal model and relating this to the island arc terrane (part a)
- explaining the role of an environmental impact statement (part b)
- understanding the difference between a prediction and general observation of the data (part c ii)
- demonstrating a clear understanding of the scientific method and the skills required for such investigations (part d i)
- using scientific principles, ideas and terminology (part e).
Question 35
Candidates showed strength in these areas:
- linking the answer to the ocean’s influence (part a)
- outlining different ways in which oceans influence the Earth’s surface (part a)
- relating the attenuation of light to the distribution of marine plants (part b)
- making effective use of the data provided in the graph to show features of two different trends (part c i)
- making use of specific data from the graph to support a prediction (part c ii)
- relating the question to the required investigation (part d i)
- demonstrating an understanding of the use of oceans as a resource (part e)
- providing a clear justification for each example of society’s changing approach (part e)
- demonstrating a coherent and logical progression of thought with effective use of scientific principles, ideas and terminology (part e).
Candidates need to improve in these areas:
- understanding the term ‘describe‘ (part a)
- providing detail of the features of TWO influences and clearly relating these to the Earth’s surface (part a)
- understanding the difference between oceans and small enclosed seas (part c ii)
- demonstrating a clear understanding of scientific method and the skills required for such investigations (part d i)
- providing specific data relating to surface area, volume and change in temperature over time (part d i).
HSC exam resources
Search for more HSC standards materials and exam packs.
Earth and Environmental Science syllabus
Find out more about the Earth and Environmental Science syllabus.
Request accessible format of this publication.