Sample work Mathematics Standard 1 Year 12: buying a car and planning a Year 12 formal
This task requires students to research and evaluate different methods for purchasing a new car and determine how much to charge people attending a Year 12 formal. See how examples have been graded, including the intended outcomes and criteria for the assessment.
Nature of the task
This task has two parts. The first part requires students to research different methods for purchasing a new car and evaluate each method. In the second part, students research the cost of holding a Year 12 Formal and determine how much to charge each person who attends the event. They use simultaneous equations to model the costs and expenses involved.
Context
Students have engaged in learning for the subtopics, Investment and Types of Relationships. They have participated in activities to develop knowledge of the concepts of spending, saving and borrowing money. They have analysed different financial situations and calculated the best options for given circumstances and to solve financial problems. They have participated in activities to develop knowledge of the concepts of simultaneous equations, graphing and interpretation of relationships, and skills to solve a variety of problems.
Outcomes assessed
MS1-12-1 uses algebraic and graphical techniques to critically evaluate arguments in a range of familiar and unfamiliar contexts
MS1-12-5 makes informed decisions about financial situations likely to be encountered post-school
MS1-12-6 represents the relationships between changing quantities in algebraic and graphical forms
MS1-12-9 chooses and uses appropriate technology effectively and recognises appropriate times for such use
MS1-12-10 uses mathematical argument and reasoning to evaluate conclusions, communicating a position clearly to others
Assessment criteria
Students will be assessed on their ability to:
- solve problems based on a scenario
- select and use appropriate mathematical processes, technologies and language to investigate problems, organise and interpret graphs and relationships
- use reasoning to evaluate solutions and justify conclusions.
Questions
Part A
You want to save money to purchase a new car. Consider three different options for saving money and evaluate each method based on its merits.
Task 1 – Find a Car
Research a brand new car that you would be interested in buying. State the make, model and cost.
Task 2 – Regular Contributions to Savings
Research interest rates for savings accounts from a bank of your choice and use a savings calculator to determine the monthly contributions you would need to make to save enough money to buy your car in 4 years’ time. Record your results.
Task 3 – Lump Sum
Use a present value calculator and the same interest rate used in Task 2 to determine how much money you would need as a lump sum to invest to achieve the same amount of savings in 4 years’ time with interest compounded monthly. Record your results.
Task 4 - Loan
Research interest rates on car loans from a bank of your choice. Use a loan calculator to determine how much you would need to pay off in total if you took out a loan to purchase the car over 4 years. Record your results.
Task 5 - Which way to go?
Based on your results, comment on the different ways of purchasing the car and evaluate each method. Include information about the availability of money, the total amount to be paid, the time until you can purchase the car and the circumstances under which you would choose each option.
Part B
You are a part of the Year 12 Formal Planning Committee and your job is to research the cost of holding the Formal and determine how much to charge each student who attends.
Task 1 – Fixed Costs
You will need to determine the cost of booking and setting up the Formal location.
Find some costs for the following in the local area:
- Hire of Venue
- Decorations
- Band/DJ
- Audio Visual Equipment
- Any other expenses (printing invites etc)
- Total Fixed Costs
Task 2 – Covering the Costs
Question 1: Write a linear equation for the Cost $C of running the event for n people using your fixed costs from Task 1 if the venue charges $45 per person for catering.
Question 2: Write a linear equation for the Income $I you will receive if n people attend if you were to charge $50 per person for tickets.
Question 3: Graph both functions using technology. Adjust the scales so that a break-even point can be clearly seen.
Question 4: How many people do you expect to attend the Year 12 Formal? By referencing your graph, will you be charging enough to cover the costs of the formal for the number of people you expect to attend?
Question 5: Given the number of people you expect to attend, calculate the actual cost per person you will need to charge and modify your equation for the Income accordingly.
Question 6: Create a new graph showing the Cost and Income for the event and clearly label the Break Even Point.
Graded student work samples
Kai
Commentary
This response demonstrates skills in using problem-solving strategies, and accuracy in using technology to perform calculations and communicate results. There is evidence of analysis and inference. Reasoning has been applied to construct a mathematical argument, but the argument has not been logically justified or clearly communicated. In Part A, detailed analysis of the findings, comparing and contrasting all aspects of the loans, has been provided. In Part B, thorough research of fixed costs and correct development of formulae is evident. An effective evaluation of ticket price has also been provided. This response demonstrates characteristics of work typically produced by a student performing at grade B standard at the end of the course.
Chris
Commentary
This response demonstrates skills in using technology to perform financial calculations but limited accuracy in using problem-solving strategies and interpreting results. Information has been applied to make predictions and draw conclusions. In Part A, The explanation of investment types is not clearly worded and does not cover all required aspects. The correct value for ‘n’ has not been used in the finance calculator, and no mathematical argument has been provided. In Part B, initial equations have been established and formulae have been correctly used. A linear relationship has been created but the break even point has not been accurately shown on the graph and equations have not been solved simultaneously to address the problem presented. Some reasoning has been provided for the correct value of the ticket. This response demonstrates characteristics of work typically produced by a student performing towards the lower end of grade C at the end of the course.
Drew
Commentary
This response demonstrates skills in using technology to perform calculations and communicate results. Information has been used to make predictions and draw conclusions, but there is some misunderstanding of terms such as ‘lump sum’, and errors in transcriptions and calculations have been made. Some follow-on questions have been correctly completed, despite errors in earlier working, but an error in understanding fixed costs meant that calculations were unable to be correctly compared. The graphing in Part B shows the break even point, and some basic reasoning has been provided. This response demonstrates characteristics of work typically produced by a student performing at grade C standard at the end of the course.